July 21


The Psychology of Cold Calling Follow-up: What Really Works

By Hanson Cheng

July 21, 2023

  • minute read
  • Last Updated on July 21, 2023 by Hanson Cheng

    Cold calling is a sales technique that involves reaching out to potential customers who have not expressed any interest in your product or service. While cold calling can be a challenging method, it remains an effective way to generate sales and increase business growth.

    The Do’s and Don’ts of Cold Calling Follow-up

    What Is Cold Calling Follow Up?

    Cold calling follow-up is a sales strategy that involves calling potential clients after an initial contact with the goal of further nurturing the relationship and ultimately closing a sale. It is a proactive approach to sales that involves taking the initiative to reach out to potential clients instead of waiting for them to come to you. Cold calling follow-up can take many different forms, including phone calls, emails, social media messages, and in-person meetings.

    It allows you to stay top-of-mind with your prospects and differentiate yourself from your competitors. Given its importance, it is crucial for sales teams to develop a comprehensive strategy for cold calling follow-up that is tailored to their business and target audience.

    Purpose Of Cold Calling Follow-up

    When it comes to cold calling, follow-up is a critical component that can make or break a sale. The purpose of the follow-up is to re-engage the prospect and continue the conversation that was started during the initial cold call. This provides an opportunity to establish a relationship with the prospect, develop trust, and ultimately, close the sale.

    The follow-up can take many forms, including phone calls, emails, or in-person meetings, and should be tailored to the individual prospect’s needs and preferences. Through effective follow-up, sales professionals can improve the success rate of their cold calls, build strong relationships with prospects, and ultimately, drive revenue for their organization.

    The Importance Of Follow Up After A Cold Call

    The follow-up process after a cold call is a critical aspect of sales that can determine the success or failure of a business. The importance of cold call follow-ups cannot be overemphasized. This process is more than just a mere call back to the potential customer; it is an opportunity to build a relationship, showcase the company’s product or service, and ultimately close a deal. The follow-up represents the customer’s perception, so it is essential to make a good impression through good communication, sharing relevant information, and being proactive.

    Follow-up calls yield valuable information about the potential customer’s needs, preferences, and motives, leading to a deeper understanding of the target audience, improving the company’s future sales strategies. Furthermore, follow-up communication creates a sense of trust between potential customers and sales representatives, building a long-term business relationship that can lead to future sales and references to other potential leads.

    Finally, failure to follow-ups attributes to low closing rates that lead to missed opportunities and revenue loss. The effort put forth in cold calling is wasted when the sale cannot be closed because the customer feels ignored or not valued. Hence, follow up calls are critical to closing deals and keeping customers engaged throughout the sales process.

    Preparing For Follow-up After Cold Calling

    Reviewing Initial Call

    Before making follow-up calls after cold calling, it is essential to review the initial call notes. Reviewing the notes ensures that you have a comprehensive understanding of the prospect’s needs and concerns. During the initial call, you may have missed important information, and reviewing the notes will help in identifying these gaps. It’s also vital to pay attention to the prospect’s tone of voice and language used during the initial call. This information will help in determining the appropriate messaging for the follow-up call.

    Furthermore, reviewing the initial call notes will help in identifying the most critical aspects of the initial conversation. This information will help in setting goals for the follow-up call. Understanding the primary goal of the follow-up call will allow you to prepare adequately for the conversation. It’s essential to prepare relevant and personalized questions for the follow-up call. The questions should be geared towards addressing the customer needs and aiming to create a solution to their problem.

    While reviewing the initial call notes, it’s imperative to analyze the prospect’s behavioral patterns. Identifying the behavioral patterns will provide insights into how to approach the follow-up call. Understanding the prospect’s behavior will allow you to tailor the conversation towards their interests, leading to a successful follow-up call. Additionally, reviewing the initial call notes will ensure that you are up to date with the conversation topics discussed during the initial call. This information will ensure that the follow-up call does not repeat topics discussed during the initial call.

    Overall, reviewing the initial call notes is crucial in ensuring that the follow-up calls are productive and focus on creating a working solution to the prospect’s issue. By paying close attention to the information gathered during the initial call, setting specific goals for the follow-up, and preparing personalized questions, you increase the chances of a successful follow-up call.

    Setting Goals

    The key to successful cold calling lies in effectively setting goals. As with any business strategy, a clear goal-setting process is critical to cold calling success. Before reaching out, it is essential to know what you are trying to achieve. This may vary from one call to the next and will likely depend on your overall business objectives.

    Some potential goals for a cold call may include gathering information, booking a meeting, or closing a sale. Once you have established your goal, consider how you can achieve it. This may involve identifying specific questions or pain points that you need to address with your potential customer. Additionally, creating a script or outline of talking points can help ensure that you stay on track and move towards achieving your goal.

    When setting goals for your cold calling strategy, it is also important to consider your target audience. Who are you calling, and what are their pain points or needs? Understanding the key motivators and interests of your potential customers is critical to successfully reaching your goals. Additionally, you may want to consider segmenting your audience and tailoring your approach based on demographic, geographic, or other relevant factors.

    Overall, setting goals is a critical step in any successful cold calling strategy. By identifying specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, and time-bound goals, you can stay focused and make the most of each cold call. Additionally, understanding your target audience and tailoring your approach accordingly can help you achieve greater success in your cold calling efforts.

    Researching Prospects

    In order to effectively follow up on a cold call, it is essential to research prospects thoroughly. This involves gathering information about the potential customer, including their background, interests, and needs. One effective way to do this is through social media platforms such as LinkedIn, Facebook, and Twitter. These platforms provide valuable insights into a prospect’s professional and personal life, allowing you to tailor your follow-up approach accordingly.

    Additionally, industry publications, company websites, and online forums can provide valuable information about a prospect’s business needs and pain points. It’s also important to identify the key decision-makers within the company, so you can focus your follow-up efforts on those with the most influence.

    Once you have collected this information, you can use it to craft a personalized message that highlights how your product or service can solve their specific challenges. By taking the time to research prospects thoroughly, you can increase your chances of making a positive impression and ultimately securing a sale.

    Preparing Materials

    Preparing materials for a cold-calling follow-up is a crucial step in setting oneself up for success. The materials should be focused on the call’s goals and the prospect’s needs. The first critical aspect of preparation is to review the initial call notes and the prospects’ background. The purpose is to gather intel on the prospect’s business, their pain points, and their decision-making process.

    One way to do this is by incorporating humor to lighten the mood. Lastly, practice makes perfect. Role-playing the call can help one gauge if the script is effective and if it flows well. Preparing materials is not a one-size-fits-all affair. It requires one to research the prospect, the company, and the industry as a whole. It takes time, but the rewards of a well-planned follow-up call are worth it.

    Effective Follow-up Techniques

    Email Follow-up

    The importance of follow-up in cold calling cannot be overstated. Once you have initiated contact with a potential customer, it’s crucial to follow-up with them via email. Email follow-up should be made promptly, within 24 hours of the phone call, and should be aimed at reminding them of the conversation you shared and the next steps to be taken. A successful email follow-up should be brief, to the point, and easy to read. It’s essential to craft an email that is courteous and professional, while also being engaging and personalized.

    A well-crafted email should start by thanking the potential customer for their time on the phone and for the opportunity to discuss their needs. It’s important to keep in mind that potential customers are inundated with emails every day, so yours should stand out. Utilize the subject line to grab their attention and highlight the purpose of the email. Make sure to use the potential customer’s name in the email; personalization is key to building relationships. Begin your email by reminding them of the benefits of your product or service and how it can suit their needs.

    Finally, always make sure to wrap up the email with a courteous closing and sincere gratitude for their time. Thank them once again for their interest and make yourself available for any additional questions or concerns they may have. The key to a successful email follow-up is to make it personal and direct, while also being clear and concise. With these tips in mind, you can make the most out of every follow-up opportunity and turn potential customers into loyal patrons.

    Phone Follow-up

    Phone follow-up is an essential aspect of cold calling that can make or break the success of the entire process. A phone call provides an opportunity to have a more personalized conversation, answer any questions the prospect may have, and establish a stronger relationship.

    When making a phone call, it’s crucial to introduce yourself and remind the prospect of your previous interaction. You should have a clear objective for the call and be prepared to articulate it concisely. It’s also important to actively listen to the prospect’s responses and adjust your approach accordingly. As with any follow-up method, persistence is key.

    If you don’t receive a response on the first attempt, try again a few days later. If you still don’t get through, it may be time to switch to a different follow-up method or re-evaluate your approach. Finally, always end the call by thanking the prospect for their time and reiterating your interest in working with them.

    Social Media Follow-up

    Social Media Follow-up is an essential aspect of the cold calling process. With the prevalence of social media platforms like LinkedIn, Twitter, and Facebook, salespeople can reach out to potential customers through these channels to follow-up on their cold calls. Through social media follow-up, salespeople can establish deeper connections with their prospects and interact with them in a more casual setting. Social media follow-up involves reaching out to prospects through social media channels, engaging with them by liking, sharing or commenting on their posts, and messaging them to reinforce the previous cold call.

    One of the most significant advantages of social media follow-up is its ability to personalize the communication between the salesperson and the prospect. Salespeople can use social media to identify their prospects’ interests, hobbies, and recent activities, creating opportunities to develop a more personal relationship with them. Personalizing the sales process can enhance the customer experience, increase the likelihood of the prospect becoming a customer, and lead to a long-term business relationship.

    Social media follow-up can also improve the efficiency of the cold calling process. By reaching out to prospects through social media, salespeople can save time and resources compared to traditional methods of follow-up such as in-person visits or phone calls. Social media platforms enable salespeople to communicate with multiple prospects simultaneously, enabling them to cover a larger pool of potential customers in a shorter amount of time.

    In conclusion, social media follow-up is a crucial aspect of the cold calling process that salespeople should incorporate into their sales strategies. It offers several benefits, including personalization, efficiency, and data insights, which can improve the chances of successfully converting prospects into customers. By using social media channels effectively, salespeople can establish more meaningful relationships with their prospects and boost their overall sales productivity.

    In-person Follow-up

    In-person follow-up is a crucial aspect of successful cold calling. Unlike other forms of follow-up, in-person follow-up provides a more personalized touch and helps establish a relationship with the prospect. When conducting in-person follow-ups, it is important to dress professionally and arrive on time to show respect for the prospect’s time.

    It is also beneficial to have a clear understanding of the prospect’s needs and concerns and be prepared to address them. Body language plays a significant role in face-to-face meetings, so maintaining appropriate eye contact and using positive gestures is essential in building trust and rapport with the prospect.

    Following up in-person also allows for the opportunity to provide physical copies of relevant materials and answer any questions the prospect may have in real-time. Overall, in-person follow-up can greatly enhance the effectiveness of cold calling and increase the chances of converting a prospect into a client.

    Best Practices For Cold Calling Follow-up

    Right Timing

    Cold calling follow-up is an essential component of any productive sales strategy. Of the various approaches employed by salespersons, timing is a critical factor for achieving maximum success. Follow-up attempts must be timely and not too frequent, striking a balance between avoiding annoyance and not missing out on opportunities.

    Understanding the time frame in which to follow up not only prevents potential customers from slipping through the cracks but also allows salespersons to make the most efficient use of their time. Timing may vary depending on various factors like industry, product, or service offered, and targeted customer. Most experts suggest that follow-up efforts should begin within 24 to 48 hours after the initial contact with a potential customer. This time frame ensures that the customer’s memory of the previous interaction is still fresh and readily accessible, thus making them more receptive to a follow-up conversation.

    Another essential factor in determining optimal follow-up timing is the product or service offered. Some industries or products may experience more extended purchasing cycles than others, requiring more persistence in follow-up attempts. In this case, the salesperson should exercise more patience and allow enough time for a potential customer to evaluate the product before making follow-up attempts.

    Finally, a salesperson should consider the customer’s schedule, including downtime and busy periods, when determining the optimal time to make follow-up attempts. This is especially true in B2B sales, where customers may have tight schedules and might not be available for a follow-up conversation at a moment’s notice. To avoid interrupting their schedule, salespeople may ask for an arrangement, allowing them to schedule follow-up attempts at a mutually convenient time.

    Be Persistent

    Persistence is a crucial component of successful cold calling follow-up. It involves the tenacity to continue reaching out to leads until a response is received. Often, a lead may not respond to initial attempts at contact or may express disinterest. However, persistent follow-up can increase the chances of success.

    Studies show that it takes an average of 8 attempts to reach a prospect with cold calling. Thus, it is vital to have a plan and a process in place that allows for continued outreach until a purchase is made or the lead is disqualified. Additionally, persistence entails maintaining consistency in communication and identifying the ideal timing for follow-up calls. A well-executed follow-up strategy that includes persistence can lead to higher lead conversion rates and increased sales opportunities.


    Personalization is a critical component of successful cold calling follow-up. It involves incorporating specific details about the prospect into the conversation to create a more intimate and engaging dialogue. Before making the initial call, research the prospect’s business, industry, and any recent news related to them.

    Use this information to personalize the opening of the call and make it more relevant to the prospect’s situation. Additionally, use the prospect’s name frequently throughout the conversation to show that you are specifically interested in them. When following up, reference any unique discussions or details from previous conversations to show that you have paid attention and remember the prospect’s specific needs. This level of personalization will increase the prospect’s engagement and make them feel more connected to the conversation.

    However, it’s crucial to find the right balance between personalization and overwhelming the prospect with too much information. The conversation should flow naturally without sounding forced or disingenuous. Personalization can take extra time and effort, but it can ultimately make the difference between a successful follow-up and a missed opportunity.

    Track Progress

    The act of tracking is crucial to effective follow-up in cold calling. By tracking relevant information such as the date and time of the initial call, information about the potential client, and any details from the conversation, sales representatives can better manage their efforts and approach.

    Without proper tracking, follow-up attempts become difficult to implement and may result in lost leads. Additionally, by keeping track of the frequency and timing of follow-up attempts, sales representatives can avoid appearing too aggressive or not persistent enough. This information allows sales teams to better customize their approach and personalize their communication, enabling them to connect with potential clients in a meaningful way.

    Overcoming Cold Calling Objections

    Common Objections

    One of the biggest challenges in cold calling follow-up is handling objections from prospects. Common objections include “not interested,” “already working with someone else,” “too busy,” or “not enough budget.” These objections can be difficult to overcome, but with the right approach, they can be addressed effectively.

    When faced with objections, it’s important to first listen attentively and acknowledge the prospect’s concerns. Often, objections are a defense mechanism for the prospect, and showing empathy and understanding can help to build rapport and establish trust. Once the objection has been identified, it can be addressed directly with relevant information or a solution that meets the prospect’s needs. Additionally, it’s important to be prepared for objection handling by anticipating common objections and creating responses ahead of time. This can help to ensure a confident and professional delivery during follow-up calls.

    Strategies for Overcoming Objections

    When making cold calls, it is common for prospects to raise objections in response to your pitch. These objections can take many forms, including price concerns, product fit, lack of immediate need, and more. While it can be tempting to give up at the first sign of an objection, experienced sales professionals know that objections are simply a natural part of the sales process, and can often be overcome with the right strategy. In this section, we will explore a variety of strategies that can be used to overcome common objections and successfully close the deal.

    One effective strategy for overcoming objections is to use empathy and active listening. When a prospect raises an objection, it is important to validate their concerns and show that you understand where they are coming from. Ask open-ended questions to gather more information and listen carefully to their responses. Then, use this information to tailor your pitch to their specific needs and concerns.

    By showing that you are truly listening and trying to understand their perspective, you can build trust and rapport with the prospect, which can make them more likely to do business with you.Another effective strategy is to use social proof. For example, you can cite case studies or testimonials from satisfied customers who were in a similar position as the prospect.

    This can help to overcome objections related to product fit or concerns about the effectiveness of the product or service. By demonstrating that others have had success with your product or service, you can build credibility and trust with the prospect, which can make them more likely to move forward with the sale.Finally, it can be helpful to address objections head-on. Instead of trying to avoid or deflect objections, address them directly and provide evidence to support your claims. For example, if a prospect raises a concern about price, you can explain the value proposition of your product or service and how it can save them money in the long run.

    Why Cold Calling Follow-up is Crucial for Sales Success

    Cold Calling Follow-up Basics

    Cold calling is an essential practice for businesses looking to generate leads and close deals. However, simply making a call is not always enough to secure a positive outcome. Follow-up is crucial in order to build relationships, establish trust, and remain top-of-mind with potential clients.

    Effective follow-up requires a strategic approach, including setting clear objectives, scheduling follow-up calls and meetings, and providing valuable information to prospects. By prioritizing follow-up and investing time and effort into building relationships with potential clients, businesses can increase their chances of success with cold calling efforts, leading to increased revenue and growth.

    Final Thoughts

    In conclusion, Cold Calling Follow-up is an essential aspect of effective sales strategies that allow businesses to build meaningful relationships with their customers. It involves the art of persistence and the ability to add value to one’s prospects by offering them personalized solutions that meet their specific needs. It also requires sales reps to be resourceful, agile, and adaptable to different customer communication preferences.

    However, successfully executing a cold calling follow-up strategy requires businesses first to understand their target audience intimately. This requires conducting thorough market research, understanding customers’ pain points and aspirations, and creating customer personas that reflect their ideal buyers’ characteristics.

    Once the groundwork is laid, businesses need to create a seamless feedback loop that provides insights into how customers are engaging with their brand and their sales reps. This means tracking and analyzing data at each step of the sales process, refining strategies based on performance metrics such as conversion rates, customer satisfaction, and customer lifetime value.

    Cold Calling Follow-up FAQs

    1. What is cold calling follow-up?

    Cold calling follow-up refers to the process of making subsequent phone calls or sending emails to a prospect who has previously been contacted through cold calling in order to cultivate a business relationship, increase the chances of making a sale, and ultimately, convince them to take action.

    2. Why is cold calling follow-up important?

    Cold calling follow-up is crucial because obtaining a sale requires more than just one phone call or email. It usually takes an average of five to eight touchpoints with a prospect to close a deal. The follow-up process keeps the relationship with the prospect alive and nurtures it, increasing the likelihood of making a sale.

    3. How do I prepare for a cold calling follow-up?

    To prepare for a cold calling follow-up, you should first review your notes from the previous call and identify what was discussed, the prospect’s needs, and any questions or concerns they may have had. You should then plan your objectives for the upcoming call, such as addressing any concerns, introducing additional features or benefits, and moving the prospect further down the sales funnel.

    Thanks For Reading!

    You can get more actionable ideas in my newsletter.

     I'll give you info on actionable ideas to grow and cool things that are getting me excited.  Enter your email and join us!

    Hanson Cheng

    About the author

    Living in Portugal with my wife and puppies.
    Scaling online businesses and sharing lessons learned on this website and in our email newsletter.

    Always happy to hear from you, so find me on Instagram if you want to say hi!

    {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}